Entertainment Report
‘My heart just dropped.’ $4 verdict shocks family of man killed by police

Four dollars.
When Monique Davis heard that was the amount a jury believed her fiancee’s mother and three children deserved for his death in a police shooting, she didn’t bother to listen to the rest of the verdict. She walked out of the courtroom, shaken.
“My heart just dropped,” Davis recalled. “It was like, are y’all serious?”
Four years earlier, her fiancee, Gregory Vaughn Hill Jr., who was black, had been shot behind his closing garage door by Christopher Newman, a white Florida sheriff’s deputy responding with a partner to a complaint of loud music. A grand jury declined to indict Newman, who said Hill had pulled a gun. Hill was found with an unloaded gun in his back pocket.
Hill’s mother then filed a wrongful death lawsuit against Newman and his boss, St. Lucie County Sheriff Ken Mascara. The case went to trial this month, and on May 24 a jury cleared Newman, assigned a small bit of blame to Mascara and said Hill was almost entirely at fault because he was drunk.
The jury tallied up the damages: $1 for funeral expenses to Hill’s mother, and $1 each to Hill’s three children, aged 7, 10 and 13.
The decision astonished the family’s lawyer, John Phillips.
“I’d have rather seen a zero than have to tell the children that their pain and suffering for losing their father is only a dollar,” he said Thursday.
Which is what the family will probably get in the end.
Because the jury assigned just 1 percent of negligence to Mascara, that $4 in damages was automatically reduced to 4 cents, Phillips said. But even that was made irrelevant by the jury’s finding that Hill’s intoxication made him 99 percent negligent. In doing so, the jury effectively erased any damages, Phillips said.
That convoluted verdict left Phillips wondering whether the jury, after about 10 hours of deliberations, understood what it was doing — and if so, whether the jurors saw the damage amount as some sort of punishment.
“Either it was punitive or they viewed these children’s pain as virtually worthless,” Phillips said.
Answers to those questions may never come. None of the jurors has spoken publicly, and they are not required to justify their verdict.
Newman and his partner, Deputy Edward Lopez, responded to Hill’s Fort Pierce home on Jan. 14, 2014 after someone from a school across the street called to complain of loud music, police have said. The deputies knocked, and Hill, 30, on disability leave from a Coca-Cola warehouse, pulled open the garage door. Seeing the officers, he started to close the door — and pulled out a gun, police said. Newman opened fire, his bullets piercing the door. Hill was found dead inside with an unloaded gun in his back pocket.
Phillips disputed that Hill raised the gun toward the officers, questioning how the weapon ended up in his back pocket before he died.
Phillips is preparing file a motion for a new trial, based on what he says were inconsistencies in the way Hill’s gun was used as evidence during the trial, and prosecutors’ revealing that Hill had been on probation at the time of the shooting for a drug charge.
After the verdict, Mascara released a statement saying his office was “pleased to see this difficult and tragic incident come to a conclusion.” Newman, he added, “was placed in a very difficult situation, and like so many law enforcement officers must do every day, he made the best decision he could given the circumstances he faced.”
Lawyers who represented Newman and Mascara did not respond to a request for comment.
Davis, 35, has been raising Hill’s three children — the two oldest of whom she had with him — with her boyfriend.
After last week’s verdict, she went home, and for two days could hardly get out of bed, wondering how she was going to explain it to the kids. She finally tried, and she said the children were struggling with it in their own ways.
Davis wants the police to admit they did something wrong, that they reacted too quickly, and she wants them to change the way they handle such situations.
“I won’t give up until proper justice is served,” she said.
How that might happen, she isn’t sure.
By: NBC Palm Springs
June 1, 2018

Latest Instagram Posts
☕️Social Time with Thalia & Jerry: White meat, dark meat, or vegetarian?
Social Time with Thalia & Jerry: cooler weather is headed our way!
🥅🔥 EIGHT ROUNDS. ONE BIG WIN. THE FIREBIRDS GET IT DONE! 🔥 No goals in overtime meant it was time for a shootout thriller at Acrisure Arena — and the Firebirds delivered! Eduard Sale and John Hayden came through in the first six rounds, while Ostman made clutch saves to keep Coachella Valley alive. Then, in the eighth round, JUGNAUTH SEALED THE DEAL! 🚨 The eight-round shootout is officially the longest in Firebirds franchise history, breaking the previous record of seven rounds. Now THAT’S how you finish a game! 🐦🔥🏒 #Firebirds #CVFirebirds #CoachellaValley #AcrisureArena #Hockey ShootoutWin
Headline: He Cleans Wheelchairs for FREE — And the Story Behind It Is Amazing! At just 21 years old, Dean Lopez is turning his passion for car detailing into something much bigger. After a simple act of kindness went viral, he and his business partner began cleaning and restoring wheelchairs for free. They’ve already helped hundreds of people, including veterans and wheelchair athletes. And Dean says it’s something he never wants to stop doing. Watch his inspiring story! #ActsOfKindness #WheelchairCommunity #GoodNews #NBCPalmSprings #CommunityHeroes
Remember shopping at Toys “R” Us? The iconic toy retailer is making a comeback just in time for the holidays! Toys “R” Us has opened more than 160 standalone stores nationwide, including locations in California. Some even feature candy shops and cafes! And there’s more: a new store is planned for New York City’s Grand Central Terminal. Looks like the holiday wish list just got a little longer! #ToysRUs #HolidayShopping #RetailNews #NBCPalmSprings #CoachellaValley

Who makes the NBC Top 3, winner will be announced Sunday night on NBC Palm Springs, with the player who makes the number one spot winning a $250 prize from @hondaofthedesert! Comment below if it will be 1) Jadarius Hester with the jump pass TD, 2) Anthony Hodge with the rushing TD, 3) Jayden Ayers with the rushing TD, 4) Jacob Vann with the Saftey, or 5) Jadarius Hester with the rushing TD #hondaofthedesert #fnl #fridaynightlights #fyp #highschoolfootball
Meet Linda from Memphis. 👋 After hours of flight delays at Palm Springs International Airport (PSP), Linda and other stranded passengers found themselves without food vouchers, hotel accommodations or even food options once airport restaurants and vending machines closed. Why were there no food options available at PSP for passengers stranded at the airport last night? Have a similar experience or additional information? Email our newsroom at news@nbcpalmsprings.com.
Passenger at Palm Springs International Airport, Kaitlyn James expresses frustration over airlines communications and operations during the almost 5 hour, nationwide, FAA ground stop #faa #groundstop #continuingcoverage #reactions #localnews
After over 4 hours of fully stopped departures, passengers make their way back to the Palm Springs International Airport after the nationwide ground stop was lifted #groundstop #faa #update #coachellavalley #760
You asked what those 39,000 public records actually uncovered. Here are the receipts. #therogginreport #deserthotsprings #localnews #coachellavalley #nbcpalmsprings
