First Hearing in Riverside County Animal Shelter Lawsuit Takes Place in Palm Springs

The first hearing in the ongoing lawsuit against Riverside County and its animal shelters took place today at the Riverside County Courthouse in Palm Springs. The courtroom was filled with animal advocates who came out in support of the case, which challenges the county's actions related to taxpayer funds and the treatment of shelter animals.

The lawsuit, filed in August of last year by the Walter Clark Legal Group, alleges that Riverside County CEO Jeff Van Wagenen misused taxpayer money by hiring former animal services director Erin Gettis and shelter consultant Kristen Hassen. The suit also claims the county violated the Hayden Act of 1998, a law designed to reduce the number of animals euthanized in shelters and ensure proper care for injured animals.

During the hearing, the Judge heard arguments from both sides to determine whether the case would proceed. The plaintiffs, led by Dan Bolton of the Walter Clark Legal Group, argue that the county is in violation of existing laws that protect shelter animals, including statutes that predate the Hayden Act. Bolton emphasized that these earlier laws are still enforceable and hold the county accountable for the treatment of animals in its shelters.

On the other hand, Riverside County's attorney, Christopher Lockwood, argued that the Hayden Act is an unfunded mandate, meaning the county is not obligated to follow it. However, in a document released by the Department of Animal Services last May, the county stated that it adheres to all current mandates of the Hayden Act, which contradicts Lockwood’s argument.

This legal battle is drawing attention amid promises from Riverside County Supervisor Manuel Perez, who recently vowed to make the county a "no-kill" county. However, advocates are concerned that the county is not following through on its promises by challenging the lawsuit, which they argue could help create the no-kill environment the supervisor has pledged.

Both sides have until March 21st to file their next briefings, and the judge will then decide whether the case has enough evidence to move forward. NBC Palm Springs Mary Strong has been following this story and has more on the court proceedings.